Price units
Identify per metre, per yard, per kilogram or another stated basis. Retain the original quotation. A metre-yard conversion uses 1 yard = 0.9144 metres and should be labelled as a calculation.
Width basis
Record finished usable and total width separately. Different cutting yields can make apparently similar length prices difficult to compare. Do not infer usable width from an unspecified figure.
Sample and test scope
Ask which development, sample metreage and laboratory costs are included. Identify the applicable article and report scope. Unknown fees should remain questions, not zero costs.
Packing and freight
Record the requested delivery basis and included packing or transport elements. Keep exclusions visible. An unconfirmed transport figure should not be added as though it were a supplier quotation.
Currency and validity
Retain each original currency and validity date. Different currencies are not directly ranked without an explicit exchange-rate basis. Review all technical and commercial differences before making a purchasing decision.
Check technical equivalence before calculating
Compare composition, construction, finish, finished weight, usable width and sample status. If articles differ, record the differences as part of the decision rather than disguising them with a converted price. Ask the garment factory about consumption where width, repeat or direction changes.
Keep currency and quoted unit unchanged in the original fields. Unknown freight, testing, sampling or other charges should remain unknown until confirmed. The comparison worksheet organises proposals; it does not infer missing costs or select a winner.
Worked example: price per yard versus price per metre
Assume proposal A is 10.00 units of one currency per yard. Since 1 yard equals 0.9144 metres, its calculated price per metre is 10.00 ÷ 0.9144, approximately 10.94 in that same currency. Proposal B at 10.80 per metre appears lower only on that unit basis.
Before choosing, compare width, specification and included scope. This hypothetical calculation is not a supplier quotation, an exchange-rate conversion or a landed-cost estimate. Retain the original prices and show the calculation separately.
Normalise the fabric quote before ranking the price
Keep the original supplier quotation and create a separate comparison line for the same article, revision and quantity scope. Record currency, quoted unit, usable width, relevant weight basis, colour split and sample stage. Identify any calculation needed to compare units and retain its inputs. If the offers describe different materials, label them as alternatives instead of making the spreadsheet imply that they are interchangeable. A precise converted number does not resolve an unconfirmed material or quantity basis.
Check whether the proposed garment consumption uses the actual usable width and accepted direction or motif arrangement. Keep provisional layout assumptions visible. Ask for missing inputs rather than assigning convenient values to complete the ranking. Compare the commercial proposal alongside the material questions still open. This allows purchasing to understand why an apparently lower unit price may not lead to the lowest cost for the accepted garment, without presenting a planning estimate as a confirmed delivery quantity or a universal measure of fabric value.
Separate quoted items, exclusions and buyer assumptions
Ask each supplier to state which material, processing, sample, assessment or other relevant items are included in its proposal and which remain separate. Keep the delivery term and named point or place clear where they form part of the quote. Confirm the agreed scope with the responsible commercial parties rather than interpreting a short trade-term label as a complete cost schedule. Use the current official ICC material when clarification of an Incoterms reference is needed; the worksheet does not replace the actual agreement.
Show buyer planning assumptions in their own fields. An estimated onward cost or an unresolved charge should not be displayed as a confirmed supplier inclusion. Keep the source, date and quantity basis of any estimate and avoid inventing charges or rates to make every line look complete. Where the included scope differs, explain the difference before ranking totals. This creates a practical comparison while leaving legal, tax, customs and contractual interpretation to the relevant parties and qualified advisers for the actual transaction.
Compare alternatives through their sample and garment consequences
Identify what changes with the lower-price proposal. Another composition, usable width, finish or colour arrangement may affect the garment layout, making work, evidence needed or acceptance scope. Preserve the original physical reference and request an identified sample for the proposed alternative. Ask the garment factory which practical comparisons are affected. A sales description such as similar quality is not a substitute for recording the actual difference and the requirements that still need review.
Keep the assessment cost, quantity and timing consequences visible in the decision, using confirmed information where available and clearly labelled assumptions elsewhere. If one offer is ready for a defined use while another remains a development proposal, retain those statuses. Purchasing can select a promising option for further work without pretending that every offer has reached the same stage. The final choice should identify the material and commercial basis accepted, together with the unresolved conditions, rather than forwarding only the cheapest numerical cell to production.
Reconfirm the selected quote after the material or quantity basis changes
Check the quotation identity, date, stated validity and assumptions against the current proposed order. A change in article, colour split, quantity, usable width, evidence requirements or delivery scope may require a revised response. Keep the previous quote intact and show the changed fields. Do not edit the supplier document to make an older proposal appear current. Ask the responsible commercial owner to confirm which version is intended to govern the next step.
Reconcile the selected response with the specification, accepted sample and schedule. If an item remains provisional, retain its status and the information needed to close it. Keep any authorised exception or alternative clearly scoped. The handover should allow another team member to understand which material is being bought and what the price covers without reconstructing the negotiation. A useful quote comparison ends with an identified current proposal and an accountable decision, not a price ranking built from mismatched articles and unexplained estimates.
Worked example: a kilogram quotation needs a weight basis
Assume a hypothetical fabric has 400 GSM and a total conversion width of 1.50 metres. Its calculated linear mass is 0.60 kilograms per metre. A quotation of 12.00 currency units per kilogram would therefore correspond to 7.20 per metre on those stated inputs.
If the weight or conversion width is unknown, leave the calculation unresolved. Record usable cutting width separately and check the actual quoted basis. The example explains arithmetic and does not establish an available fabric, price, measurement method or commercial commitment.
Resolve the gaps that could change the comparison
Ask each proposal to identify validity, quantity by colour, sample or development scope, trade term and named place where used, and included or excluded items. If currencies differ, retain them rather than ranking the prices without an agreed conversion basis.
Record clarification responses with the proposal ID and date. Review the complete technical and commercial fit with the responsible buyer. A transparent comparison may conclude that more evidence is needed; that is more useful than an apparent saving created by incompatible units or missing costs.
Prepare the next decision
| Input | Decision to make | Record to keep |
|---|---|---|
| Unit | Original quoted basis | Price record |
| Width | Usable and total | Cutting basis |
| Development | Samples and tests | Included scope |
| Delivery | Packing and freight | Exclusions |
| Validity | Currency and date | Current proposal |
Questions for this stage
Does the tool rank different currencies?
No. It keeps original currencies and does not assume an exchange rate.
Can unknown costs be treated as zero?
No. Leave them open and request the missing scope or fee.
Is a converted price a new supplier offer?
No. It is a labelled calculation based on the original quoted unit.
Can I choose the cheapest converted price?
The calculation addresses one unit difference. Compare the article, usable width, garment consumption, currency and scope before making a commercial decision; unconfirmed costs and differences remain part of the review.
What if one quotation excludes testing or freight?
Keep the exclusion visible and request the actual amount or responsibility needed for comparison. Do not enter zero for an unknown cost or assume both proposals include the same items.
Is the lowest price per metre necessarily the lowest fabric cost per garment?
Compare the accepted article, usable width, cutting arrangement and quantity required for the actual garment. Keep direction, matching, material exclusions and any other relevant work visible. Different offers may also include different commercial items or remain at different development stages. Reconcile those bases before ranking the result. A lower metre price is useful information, but it does not establish the lowest cost or suitability of a completed accepted garment by itself.
Can a blank quote-comparison field be treated as an included charge?
Mark the item as unconfirmed and ask the supplier or responsible commercial party to clarify it. A blank can mean omitted information, a separate proposal or an assumption that has not been discussed. Keep confirmed inclusions, exclusions and buyer estimates in different fields. Do not enter an invented value or interpret silence as agreement simply to complete a total. Retain the original quotation and connect the clarification to its actual revision and order scope.
Should a revised colour split use the earlier quotation automatically?
Check the stated scope and assumptions of the earlier proposal and request confirmation where the changed split affects the material or commercial basis. Keep the previous quote and the new requirement identifiable. Reconcile any related minimum, sample, availability or schedule response. An older price can remain useful history, but it should not be presented as a current accepted offer for a different order combination unless the responsible parties have confirmed that scope.